Montana-Dakota Sugarbeet Growers Association expresses disappointment about closure of Sidney Sugars factory

"We, the growers, are disappointed in American Crystal Sugar’s decision in closing our local Sidney, Montana, factory."

American Crystal Sugar on Monday, Feb. 6, 2023, announced it is closing the Sidney Sugars processing plant in Sidney, Montana.
Mikkel Pates / Agweek file photo

(Editor's note: American Crystal Sugar on Feb. 6, 2023, announced it is closing the Sidney Sugars processing plant in Sidney, Montana. The Montana-Dakota Beet Growers Association Board, which has grown beets for the plant, submitted this statement in response.)

For almost the last 100 years,the sugarbeet producers in our area have been recognized as some of the best sugarbeet growers in the nation. We have always taken pride in growing the highest quality crop possible every year. We, the growers, are disappointed in American Crystal Sugar's decision in closing our local Sidney, Montana, factory.

The growers of our association have made every attempt to keep Sidney Sugars a viable operation, ever since it was purchased by American Crystal Sugar Company in 2002. Unfortunately, the sugarbeet growers of our area have never had a clear sight of how we fit into American Crystal Sugar’s future. For 20 years, the growers have had to negotiate a new contract with American Crystal Sugar Company every three years on average. During these negotiations, the sugar beet growers of this valley have been required to take substantial reductions in payments in order to keep American Crystal Sugar Company’s operation in our area profitable enough for them.

Read more news from Agweek:
Get all your ag news at
American Crystal Sugar Co., based in Moorhead, Minnesota, announced on Monday, Feb. 6, that it was going to close the Montana plant because Montana-Dakota Beet Growers Association farmers who grow sugarbeets for the company showed there no longer was adequate interest in growing enough of the crop to sustain operations.
Last year's harvest shortfall left corn supplies at their lowest since 2013 and made farmers hopeful that prices would rally in the coming months.
Commercial farmers in Nebraska, the Dakotas, and Minnesota start using drones for spraying, seeding.
Kevin and Lynette Thompson brought TNT Simmental Ranch to life in 1985. Now, their daughter, Shanon Erbele, and her husband, Gabriel, are taking over the reins, and their sale is for Feb. 10.

During these years, the willingness of our area’s growers to adopt new technologies has risen yields to deliver more than enough production to keep the factory profitable. This adaptation of technology by our growers, and the sacrifices required of them in contracts, is the only reason we have been sustainable through these years of new ownership.

American Crystal Sugar Company has referenced that 30,774 acres were grown in crop year 2021. That marked the end of a contract period and a new negotiation ensued. The reduction in acres to crop year 2022 was a direct result of that negotiation process. During this time the growers were told by an American Crystal Sugar’s executive that we would be required to take another large cut to our payments and we should expect continued cuts in our subsequent contracts.


The growers of this association recognize that American Crystal Sugar's presence in our area has come and gone, but our sugarbeet growers' dedication to this region will continue for generations to come. We would like to thank our local Sidney Sugars employees for their years of dedication to Sidney, Montana. Our thank-yous do not end there. The businesses and people of our community have been the bedrock that has held up and continue to hold up many of our operations. Our sugarbeet growers will be required to transition into a new way of life, and we ask for your continued support.

We were just informed by American Crystal Sugar of the closing this morning, and while this news is still fresh in our hearts, we understand the importance of a statement from our board. We hope to give you further comment in the future.


Montana-Dakota Beet Growers Association Board

What To Read Next
Get Local