ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Farmers: What would you say to this man?

I heard recently about an agriculturalist who believes strongly that farmers should have three goals: 1. Protect the Earth, the overriding priority.2. Benefit society, provided the Earth is protected.3. Make a profit, but only if the first two go...

4037051+earthimage.jpg

I heard recently about an agriculturalist who believes strongly that farmers should have three goals:

1. Protect the Earth, the overriding priority.
2. Benefit society, provided the Earth is protected.
3. Make a profit, but only if the first two goals are met.

I can almost hear the howls of protest from Agweek readers. The overwhelming majority will argue he has those priorities exactly backward, and insist that your farming operation achieves all three goals (though profits are sometimes elusive).

I don't know the aggie in question, so it's risky to speculate about his motives or level of agricultural knowledge. But I'd guess he's a smart, well-intentioned guy who doesn't understand the realities of modern agriculture.

My response to his agenda? I'd tell him that farming is first and foremost a business, and farmers need to make a profit. And I might add the classic line from Adam Smith defending the profit motive: "It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker, that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own interest."

ADVERTISEMENT

If you had a chance to talk with the man, what would you say -- respectfully and constructively -- to him?

Read more of my blogs at www.agright.areavoices.com .

 

Opinion by Jonathan Knutson
Plain Living
What To Read Next