Veterinarian: Lawsuits build against prescription pet food, bird flu appears in cats

Dear Readers: Attorneys in California, Minnesota, Georgia and North Carolina filed a class action lawsuit against the leading manufacturers and sellers of pet food: Mars, Nestle Purina, Hills, PetSmart and several veterinary hospital chains in Ca...


Dear Readers: Attorneys in California, Minnesota, Georgia and North Carolina filed a class action lawsuit against the leading manufacturers and sellers of pet food: Mars, Nestle Purina, Hills, PetSmart and several veterinary hospital chains in California on Dec. 7. The four main pet food brands involved in the suit include Hill's Prescription Diet, Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Diets, Royal Canin Veterinary Diet and Iams Veterinary Formula. Mars, the biggest seller of pet food, sells two of the four prescription pet food brands and is also the owner of the largest veterinarian hospital chain the United States, BluePearl Vet Hospital.

Mars also partners with the largest specialty pet retailer, PetSmart, in the ownership of the largest veterinarian clinic chain, Banfield Pet Hospital. The suit concerns prescription pet foods that cost more, but that plaintiffs contend are no different than any other kind of pet food. Some highlights in this complaint:

  • "Defendants' prescription pet food contains no drug or other ingredient not also common in non-prescription pet food."
  • "Defendants' marketing, labeling and/or sale of prescription pet food is deceptive, collusive and in violation of federal antitrust law and California consumer-protection law."
  • "Defendants are engaged in an anticompetitive conspiracy to market and sell pet food as prescription pet food to consumers at above-market prices that would not otherwise prevail in the absence of their collusive prescription-authorization requirement."

As documented in the book "Not Fit for a Dog: The Truth About Manufactured Cat and Dog Food," which I co-authored with two other veterinarians in 2009, the claims being made by the providers of overpriced, often unpalatable and nutrient deficient prescription-only manufactured pet foods are generally questionable and often lacking in sound clinical and scientific evidence of being of any benefit.
Dear Dr. Fox: I have a 13-year-old beagle-shepherd-Lab mix named Nibbles. At her last vet appointment, her tests showed kidney problems.

Up until that point, she had always been eating Nutro Max dog food and was on the senior formula. The vet, who I've gone to for years and do trust, put her on new food, Hills Prescription Diet k/D Kidney Support, which has "less phosphorus, protein and salt," or so he said.

Looking at this food's ingredients and comparing them with Nutro Max, I think this new food has a lot more junk ingredients in it and more fat.


Now, if this diet works despite all the crap ingredients, then fine. The issue is, prior to the diagnosis, I had seen no sign of kidney issues. Now, after about a month on this food, she seems very antsy and anxious; she pees more than she used to, drinks more than she used to and seems hungrier. The main reason I am writing is that last night, she wet the bed (she released her whole bladder). This has never happened before. The reason she went to the vet in the first place was merely for a senior exam, during which I mentioned her recently insatiable appetite and her weight loss (she's lost about 5 pounds). Her whole life, she's received a half-cup of food in the morning and a half-cup at night. We upped it to an extra half-cup in the past year, and now with the new kidney support diet, we upped it to 2 full cups a day.

Is this recent bed-wetting and altered behavior part of the kidney cleansing process? Or is this making her issue worse? To me, it seems like the less I feed her, the better (for example, go back to only 1 cup of food per day), but she is so hungry, and that also seems kind of mean. She also takes a kidney-support vitamin (VetriSCIENCE). - H.P., Washington, D.C.

Dear H.P.: Dogs with chronic kidney disease, when accurately diagnosed, need careful monitoring of blood pressure, dietary phosphate, potassium and blood urea nitrogen, as per my article on kidney disease posted on my website, . The ingredients in the special prescription diet are of dubious value, possibly harmful and certainly not providing your dog with sufficient nutrients if she is constantly hungry. This is no way to go. Chronic kidney disease can lead to sarcopenia, wasting of muscles due to the kidneys passing out more protein. So your dog needs some good-quality protein in her daily diet.

Dogs with kidney disease drink more, so take your dog out more frequently to urinate. But this, coupled with the increased appetite, could be related to diabetes, which I would have your dog checked for, along with a blood test to see how her kidneys are functioning. Do keep me posted on the outcome, and good luck.

Bird influenza virus infects cats

Avian influenza H7N2, identified by the Wisconsin Veterinary Diagnostic Laboratory at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, infected at least 45 feline residents of the Animal Care Center shelter in Manhattan, marking the first documented instance of infection and transmission of H7N2 among domestic cats. Most affected cats exhibited mild symptoms, but one elderly cat with other health problems died, and testing is underway to ensure no humans or other species of animal at the center have been infected.

Send all mail to  or to Dr. Michael Fox in care of Universal Uclick, 1130 Walnut St., Kansas City, MO 64106. The volume of mail received prohibits personal replies, but questions and comments of general interest will be discussed in future columns. Visit Dr. Fox's website at .

What To Read Next
This week on AgweekTV, we hear about North Dakota corporate farming legislation and about WOTUS challenges. Our livestock tour visits a seedstock operation and a rabbit farm. And we hear about new uses for drones.
Kevin and Lynette Thompson brought TNT Simmental Ranch to life in 1985. Now, their daughter, Shanon Erbele, and her husband, Gabriel, are taking over the reins, and their sale is for Feb. 10.
Gevo will be making sustainable aviation fuel in Lake Preston, South Dakota. Summit Carbon Solutions plans to capture carbon emissions from the facility.
Even if it's not a lucrative venture, the hobby of raising rabbits continues at this farm near Sebeka, Minnesota.